Tax-inclusive vs tax-exclusive organization behavior
Organizations operating in tax-inclusive jurisdictions (for example, VAT/GST countries where displayed prices include tax) have fundamentally different loyalty point behavior compared to tax-exclusive organizations (where tax is added on top of the displayed price). This article explains how tax settings interact with loyalty point calculations.
On this page
- Before you begin
- Tax-exclusive organizations
- Tax-inclusive organizations
- Behavior comparison
- Common configuration patterns
- Invoice restrictions in tax-inclusive mode
- Gift card redemption in tax-inclusive mode
- Related articles
Before you begin
- This article is relevant if your organization operates in a tax-inclusive jurisdiction or if you are evaluating which accrual base to use.
- The key settings discussed are: Enable tax-inclusive pricing, Loyalty points accrual using, and Allow LP redemption with post-accrual.
Tax-exclusive organizations
In tax-exclusive organizations, prices displayed in the system do not include tax. Loyalty point calculations use the pre-tax amount:
- Points are calculated on the sale price minus discounts (pre-tax).
- Tax is subtracted from the calculation before dividing by the exchange rate.
- The maximum redemption percentage is calculated on the pre-tax base.
- Both web UI and API redemption are fully supported.
Tax-inclusive organizations
In tax-inclusive organizations, displayed prices already include tax. When loyalty point redemption is enabled:
- Points are calculated on the tax-inclusive price.
- Tax is not subtracted from the calculation.
- The maximum redemption percentage includes tax in the base amount.
- Redemption may have restrictions depending on configuration.
When Allow LP redemption with post-accrual is enabled, the web UI supports loyalty point redemption. However, certain restrictions apply:
- Undoing a membership application, package application, or campaign application is blocked when loyalty point or gift card redemptions exist on the invoice. You must first undo the redemption, then undo the benefit.
Behavior comparison
| Aspect | Tax-exclusive | Tax-inclusive (with LP enabled) |
|---|---|---|
| Accrual base | Pre-tax amount | Tax-inclusive amount |
| Tax in calculation | Subtracted | Included |
| Max redemption base | Pre-tax amount | Full tax-inclusive amount |
| Web UI redemption | Supported | Supported (when post-accrual enabled) |
| Undo membership/package/campaign | Allowed with redemptions | Blocked when redemptions exist |
Common configuration patterns
| Pattern | Description |
|---|---|
| Standard (US/tax-exclusive) | Pre-tax accrual; full support; no restrictions |
| Tax-inclusive, LP disabled | Post-tax accrual; redemption blocked |
| Tax-inclusive, LP enabled | Post-tax via tax-inclusive prices; web UI redemption only; undo restrictions apply |
| Hybrid | Org shows inclusive prices but LP accrues on pre-tax; full support |
Invoice restrictions in tax-inclusive mode
When the organization uses tax-inclusive pricing and loyalty point or gift card redemptions exist on an invoice, the following actions are blocked:
- Undo membership application
- Undo package application
- Undo campaign application
The restriction exists because undoing a benefit after a tax-inclusive redemption would require recalculating the redemption value. You must first undo the loyalty point or gift card redemption, then undo the benefit.
Gift card redemption in tax-inclusive mode
For tax-inclusive organizations, gift card redemption behavior depends on whether the gift card was sold with or without tax:
- Gift card sold without tax -- Treated as a payment
- Gift card sold with tax -- Treated as a redemption (reduces the amount due)