Afterpay dispute handling
When a guest pays using Afterpay (a Buy Now Pay Later payment method), disputes follow a distinct path within Zenoti's Disputes management feature. Unlike standard card disputes, Afterpay disputes skip the pre-dispute inquiry stage and are treated as chargebacks immediately upon creation. This article explains how to monitor Afterpay disputes in the Disputes management dashboard and how to upload evidence to defend them.
Audience: Finance managers and center administrators who manage payment disputes on behalf of their organization.
Before you begin
- Your organization must have Afterpay enabled as a payment method through Stripe Express. For payment processor setup, see the Integrations category.
- You must have access to the Disputes management dashboard within Zenoti Payments.
- Understand that Afterpay disputes differ from standard card disputes in two important ways:
- There is no pre-dispute (inquiry) stage — every Afterpay dispute is created immediately as a chargeback.
- The disputed amount is debited from your payable balance immediately when the dispute is created, and a dispute fee is charged at the same time.
Permission: You need the Dispute Payments permission (under Payments) to view and respond to disputes in the Disputes management dashboard. Admin path: Configuration > Security > Security roles > [your role] > Permissions > Payments > Dispute Payments
Important: Zenoti does not generate automatic evidence for Afterpay disputes. You must manually upload all evidence to defend an Afterpay dispute. Prepare your supporting documentation before the response deadline shown on the dispute record.
Steps
View an Afterpay dispute
- Navigate to the payment dashboard.
- Open the Disputes management dashboard.
- Locate the dispute you want to review. Afterpay disputes appear alongside standard card disputes in the same dashboard view.
- Select the dispute to open its detail view.
- Review the following information on the dispute record:
- Dispute lifecycle status — The current status of the dispute (for example, Requested, Initiated, Won, Lost, Rejected, or Invalid).
- Evidence submission requirements — The deadline by which you must submit evidence and the types of documentation accepted.
- Money movement details — Confirms that the disputed amount has been debited from your payable balance and that a dispute fee has been charged.
Note: The response deadline is set by the card network at the time the dispute is created. Check the dispute record for the exact deadline applicable to each dispute — deadlines are not fixed values and vary per dispute.
Upload evidence to defend an Afterpay dispute
Important: Because Zenoti does not generate automatic evidence for Afterpay disputes, you must gather and upload all supporting documentation yourself before the deadline shown on the dispute record.
- Open the dispute record in the Disputes management dashboard.
- Review the evidence submission requirements listed on the dispute.
- Gather your supporting documentation. Relevant evidence typically includes:
- Proof of service delivery or product fulfillment
- Guest communication records
- Signed agreements or receipts
- Any other documentation that supports your position
- Upload your evidence files using the evidence submission controls on the dispute record.
- Select Defend Dispute, then Confirm before the deadline shown on the dispute.
Tip: Submit evidence as early as possible. Disputes that miss the response deadline are automatically closed in the guest's favor.
Understand money movement for Afterpay disputes
When an Afterpay dispute is created:
- The disputed amount is immediately debited from your organization's payable balance.
- A dispute fee is charged immediately at the time of dispute creation.
If you win the dispute:
- The disputed amount is returned to your payable balance.
- The dispute fee is typically not refunded — confirm the specific terms with your processor agreement.
If you lose the dispute:
- The debited amount remains with the guest.
- The dispute fee is not returned.
Note: The dispute fee amount varies by processor contract. The exact fee is shown on the dispute record in the Disputes management dashboard.
Tips
- Check the dashboard regularly. Afterpay disputes are created immediately as chargebacks with no inquiry stage, so there is no advance warning before the response deadline begins counting down. Review the Disputes management dashboard frequently to catch new disputes early.
- Prepare evidence templates in advance. Because you must manually upload all evidence for Afterpay disputes, having a standard set of documentation templates (service delivery confirmations, guest communication logs) ready before a dispute arises reduces response time.
- Track your payable balance after dispute creation. The debit happens immediately when the dispute is created — not when it is resolved. Monitor your payable balance in the payment dashboard to account for funds held during open disputes.
Troubleshooting
| Problem | Resolution |
|---|---|
| An Afterpay dispute does not appear in the Disputes management dashboard | Confirm that the transaction was processed through Afterpay via Stripe Express. Disputes for other payment methods appear in the same dashboard but are separate entries. If the dispute is still missing, allow up to a few minutes for the status to update, then refresh the dashboard. |
| The evidence upload controls are not available on the dispute record | Check the dispute lifecycle status. Evidence submission is only available for disputes in an active response window (status: Requested or Initiated). Disputes with a status of Won, Lost, Rejected, or Invalid are closed and no longer accept evidence. |
| The disputed amount was debited but the dispute record shows no fee | Dispute fees are charged immediately at creation. If no fee is visible on the record, check your payable balance history in the payment dashboard. If the discrepancy persists, contact your processor support for a transaction-level breakdown. |